Reading Waves and Riding Bandwagons

by · May 20, 2010

Most “historians” believe the first guy to ride a bandwagon was a politician who wanted to get some face time. Word has it that he literally hopped on a wagon carrying a band during a parade, giving us a fitting phrase to describe the  countless men and women who have seized the opportunity to jump on board the latest thing and give it a ride.

I have always been amazed at the way ideas and behaviors spread among people. While some fads and trends occur as a result of innovation or practical usefulness, many happen simply because the bandwagon is conveniently rolling down Main Street.

This is largely due to a humbling reality about humanity… we often act like sheep. We believe and act in certain ways simply because of how other people believe and act. We call this the “herd instinct”- when people follow the crowd without ever really asking or knowing why, it is just the thing to do. (What else would explain the popularity of parachute pants, Cabbage Patch Kids, waterbeds, and Keesha.)

There is, however, an alternative, if not a precursor to band wagons.

I am in no way an experienced surfer, but I do know a little about riding a wave. Waves are literally fluid- they are always changing. Because of this, wave riders must first become wave readers- a highly organic process that requires patience and a great deal of waiting and watching.

I have watched surfers ride waves on both East Coast and West Coast waves. I have watched them surf Gulf of Mexico waves and North Shore waves. Regardless of location, it all works the same way… sit on your board and watch the horizon. There is an intuitive process that happens as you try to spot the next set rolling in.

If we were to zoom out on the modern church timeline, we would be able to see some significant movements over the past few decades revealing both bandwagon riders and wave riders.

In the sixties, a guy named Chuck Smith caught a wave that turned into something called the “Jesus People” movement (bandwagon name- Calvary Chapel). Thanks to Chuck for helping churches become more accessible to the disenfranchised.

Bill Hybels caught a wave in the seventies that became Willow Creek Church (bandwagon name- Willow Creek Association). We can thank Bill for introducing things like drama, creative arts and the value of leadership in the church.

The next wave went back to “SoCal” in the 80’s with a fellow named Rick Warren. His wave started a church called Saddleback (bandwagon name- Purpose Driven Churches).  We can credit Rick with helping churches to be more intentional and for influencing thousands of fifty-plus year old pastors to wear Hawaiian print shirts.

So what does this all mean?

First, let me be clear that riding a bandwagon is not a bad thing. Bandwagons are often necessary to help move large groups of people into something better, to make progress or just to stay current. But, while God often uses bandwagon riders, he also uses and needs wave riders to advance his kingdom. Why? Because every movement has a beginning.

Movements never begin by riding a bandwagon. Movements always begin by riding a wave. While God can and will use bandwagons to move and influence his people, he often leads men and women to do something that has never been done before. In fact, the distinguishing mark of a true leader is someone who is willing to do something that has never been done before (or that few others are doing). It is someone who acts not because the masses are doing it or because it is “the thing” to do, but simply because they have a strong sense of conviction that God is saying, “Do this.”

This is happening right now. God is speaking. He is leading. He has a plan and a purpose for his church that he is revealing to his people- the next set is rolling in. Some are watching the horizon, others the band. The only question is what we will be riding… the wave or the wagon.

  • Geoff

    What about the last 2 decades? Why haven't you named the wave and bandwagon? I'd be interested in hearing what you think they are… any guesses as to the next wave?

  • http://discoverexpedition.com Donovan Christian

    Good question Geoff.

    I think that many churches are still riding either the Willow or Saddle bandwagons. It sometimes takes several years, if not a decade or more, for latecomers to jump on board (if they ever do).

    Other than those, I would identify Andy Stanley (North Point) and Ed Young (Fellowship Church) as being the wave riders of the last decade for sure. You can certainly travel to various cities around the country and see those ministry paradigms duplicated (I think that's why this video resonated with so many people: http://www.shrinkthechurch.com/2010/05/12/sunda….) I'm not sure what the generalized name for the bandwagon would be. Any ideas?

    As for the next wave, these are my guesses…

    The church will become more simple.
    Gone will be the buffet approach to ministry where churches feel like they must provide a program for every conceivable need. Followers of Jesus are realizing that the busyness and complexity of their ministries are not necessarily translating to spiritual health. Churches will become specialist, doing a few things well.

    Ministry will become more decentralized.
    Power will return to the people. We will become less dependent on “trained professionals” for ministry and more dependent on people being like Jesus to their friends, neighbors and families.

    The church will minimize the wow factor.
    Churches of the latest wave are cool! Cool buildings, cool sound systems, cool lights, cool coffee, cool bookstore, cool whatever. Don't get me wrong, I love cool! Cool is cool. But, I think the next wave will not care as much about cool as they will about depth and meaning (And no, I'm not saying cool churches are shallow.)

    The church will focus more on building THE Kingdom.
    A huge amount of resources (time/money/etc.) are spent by churches building their own kingdom. They can be very egocentric. I think the next wave will see a shift in where resources are invested.

    Those are some to get started, I would add to those things like… Less polished, more messy. Less structured, more informal/organic. Less Sunday, Sunday, Sunday, more everyday. Less perfect, more authentic.

    Would love to hear your ideas!

  • shane

    I really needed this blog we launched a church that is just like what you described it has been a struggle at times any advice

  • http://www.soontobeme.com Cody

    Great post and follow-up comments. It will be interesting to see how these waves will look if ministry is becoming more decentralized in an increasingly globalized world. Could it be that there would be multiple waves happening based on the needs and culture of each region (i.e. one wave for churches in the Bible Belt, another for churches in the northeast, etc)? I don't know. I'm mostly thinking “out loud,” but I certainly welcome a more decentralized and simple church. I think we've discovered the full extent of what programs can do.

  • http://discoverexpedition.com Donovan Christian

    Good “out loud” thoughts Cody. I think you touched on a very important aspect of the discussion.

    I've spent a good amount of time in Mexico working with a friend who is a Mexican pastor. One of the things I noticed is that they also have the tendency to jump on bandwagons, many of which are North American. These often lack relevance to their own culture thereby minimizing their potential effectiveness. The danger is in thinking “That's what successful American churches do, therefore we must do the same to be successful.”

    That's an extreme example to affirm your point about waves being “regionalized.” The application would ring true to regions, but also to things like urban/suburban/rural, socio-economic, etc. I would much rather see people in ministry try to discern what God wants them to do in their unique community.

  • http://discoverexpedition.com Donovan Christian

    Good “out loud” thoughts Cody. I think you touched on a very important aspect of the discussion.

    I've spent a good amount of time in Mexico working with a friend who is a Mexican pastor. One of the things I noticed is that they also have the tendency to jump on bandwagons, many of which are North American. These often lack relevance to their own culture thereby minimizing their potential effectiveness. The danger is in thinking “That's what successful American churches do, therefore we must do the same to be successful.”

    That's an extreme example to affirm your point about waves being “regionalized.” The application would ring true to regions, but also to things like urban/suburban/rural, socio-economic, etc. I would much rather see people in ministry try to discern what God wants them to do in their unique community.

  • http://discoverexpedition.com Donovan Christian

    Hi Shane-

    Glad the blog is helpful!

    Two things:

    1- Can you clarify on what you mean by “we launched a church that is just like what you described”? Which part of “described” is it like?

    2- What is the struggle related to?

  • http://discoverexpedition.com Donovan Christian

    Hi Shane-

    Glad the blog is helpful!

    Two things:

    1- Can you clarify on what you mean by “we launched a church that is just like what you described”? Which part of “described” is it like?

    2- What is the struggle related to?

  • http://www.soontobeme.com Cody

    Thanks, Donovan. That makes sense to me. I wonder what you'd think about another potential wave coming around regarding the future role of pastors in church. I found a blog post (http://www.bedeviant.com/bi-vocationalism-and-t…) that discusses the burnout of pastors in North America and that the future of pastoral leadership could be bi-vocational. Do you think that's a conceivable future for our churches?